What Will Buying An Investment Property In Madison Really Cost you?

Buying An Investment Property MadisonAt Wisconsin House Buyers, LLC, we frequently get emails and phone calls from other investors that are interested in buying investment property in Madison or the surrounding areas in Dane County? There’s an old saying in real estate investing, you make your money when you buy the property. Do your homework and know what to budget for before you agree to purchase the home. This will be a better outcome for the seller and you. While this article primarily focuses on rental properties, some of these same lessons apply to flipping a property as well. It’s just a smaller timeline.

Buying an investment property in Madison is a great way to increase your income. However, it is important to be prepared for your purchase by understanding all associated costs. Below we cover a few of the different types of expenses with a general idea of what you can expect to pay.

Down Payment

Learn all of your financing options. Investment properties are not eligible for FHA loans unless you are buying an owner-occupied property with 1-4 units. If you are not planning on living in the home yourself, you will likely need to use a conventional loan, which will require about 20% down. The larger down payment you are able to make, the less interest you will need to pay in the long run. If you are able to pay in cash, even better. That being said, not everybody has a ton of cash sitting on the sidelines. It’s also possible to use creative financing and still come out ahead, while potentially putting 0-5% down on the property. Now it gets really important to know your numbers because your interest rate and overall payments will be larger. Consider picking up a book or learning more about low money down investing.

Closing Costs

Typically, closing costs in Madison will run you about 2-5% of the final sale price. No matter what you do, do not skip on using a title company. If for some reason the title comes in to question down the road, you will be stuck figuring out how to pay for an attorney. There are plenty of reputable title insurance companies around the Madison area. We personally use First American Title and love them. Closing costs will include things like title search, title insurance, transfer fees, legal costs, and administrative fees. Buyers aren’t always prepared for these additional costs, so make sure you have budgeted ahead of time. You can also negotiate with the seller who will pay what, possibly arranging for them to cover the costs of closing completely on their own.


Whether you’re buying an investment property in Madison as a rental property, or as a fix and flip investment property, there will be costs for repairing the property before you can get any money back out of it. Learn about the costs of making repairs yourself versus paying subcontractors to do the work for you. Missing the mark on repair estimates can sink your entire project, regardless of the strategy. Once again, there are great resources about estimating costs out there. We can help if you have questions but ultimately, it’s about getting out in the market and applying things in real life (and getting lots of bids). Walk a property and have an itemized list of the different repairs that might need to be made. This helps to make sure you don’t miss anything.


Depending on where you live, property taxes can become a big factor when it comes to calculating your profits. Madison is certainly not one of the cheaper places to own property in the US, nor are any of the peripheral markets in Dane County. Make sure you know the tax history of the property and any local changes that will affect the amounts you are paying in the coming years. You can look up the tax history on the property appraisers site and even sites like Zillow. Use a property tax estimator to find out what you might be in for in the upcoming year. If your margins are slim and you are stuck with a property tax bill costing thousands of dollars, the property may not be the right one for you. Don’t get hit at the end of the year with a high tax bill simply because you failed to research ahead of time.


The insurance you carry for investment property will be different than your standard homeowner’s insurance policy. It is recommended that you carry $500,000-$1,000,000 in liability coverage. The policy will likely be more expensive than what you pay for your own home. It is important to make sure you have landlord protection in case you are ever sued by a tenant or someone else in regards to the property. When adding up the costs for the home, don’t neglect to include your insurance expenses.

Maintenance & Repairs

Maintenance and repairs should never be overlooked when considering the true costs of your investment property. A good rule of thumb is to budget 1% of the properties value for the minor repairs needed each year. You’ll also want to set up an emergency fund for the larger repairs¬†that will be needed over time. You’ll want to have the money available if something major breaks or for when you require a new roof, etc.

Tenant Screening

While this might be an area where you feel you can save a few bucks using your good ol’ intuition, now is not the time. It is extremely important to conduct full background¬†checks on every person applying to live in your house. Even if you already know them, and even if they are a friend or family member. Many landlords find themselves stuck with bad tenants all because they didn’t spend the time to fully check them out. Many hassles and expenses can be avoided with a fast and thorough background check.

Property Management

You may be able to handle one or two properties on your own if you know what you are doing and live nearby. But once you find yourself owning a few properties or properties out of the area you live, it will likely be time to bring in a property manager to help you with some of the associated tasks. Your property manager can help schedule repairs, handle tenant complaints, and be responsible for collecting the rent. In exchange for their services, you can expect to pay around 10% of the amount you are collecting in rent each month. That said, the right property management company can be worth their weight in gold.


Thinking about buying an investment property in Madison? We would love to help! Get in touch with us today! (608) 721-5994

Get More Info On Options To Sell Your Home...

Selling a property in today's market can be confusing. Connect with us or submit your info below and we'll help guide you through your options.

What Do You Have To Lose? Get Started Now...

We buy houses in ANY CONDITION in WI. There are no commissions or fees and no obligation whatsoever. Start below by giving us a bit of information about your property or call (608) 721-5994...
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Call Us!
(608) 721-5994

Questions? Chat with the owner directly!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.